مشاهدة جميع الاصدارات : Saleh Abd al-Hayy 78rpm recordings of adwar (episode 3)

27-04-2006, 19:30
Saleh Effendi Abd al-Hayy

dor / Ashki li-min zoll el-hawa (bayyati)
composer : Dawud Husni
Baidaphon 82127/28/29/30

circa 1923, sung by a young Saleh.

Also recorded by Munira al-Mahdeyya and Zaki Murad.

أبو علاء
27-04-2006, 21:20
Thanks, Fred. Munira's version was provided by Zeryab in his forum and I uploaded it here but the quality of the recording is not that good. As for Zaki Murad's one, I simply haven't heard it yet.

28-04-2006, 09:30
For the Zaki Murad version, I just know it exists, I've never had it or heard it either...

28-04-2006, 10:37
شكرا سيدي على هذه الملفات وما حوت من أدوار و ما حولها من معلومات وفوائد.

28-04-2006, 13:04
I posted the Zaki Mourad version here http://www.zamanalwasl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=799&highlight=zaki

abo 3arab
05-02-2007, 00:22
الف شكر لك على هذه الروائع

09-02-2007, 15:14
Ok, 1st apologies for missing this beautiful dor.

My question to you Fred is how, academically, do you compare two versions of a dor?

Let's take as an example this version of the dor sung by Salih and by Zaki Murad?

عامر حريري
10-02-2007, 15:04
شكراً لك سيدي الكريم
لقد أعدتني الى زمن جميل
مع تحياتي